Evening Standard  
Thursday 30 January 2003
Theatre cries out for a dream-struck staging that matches  and catches the original. Rarely can stage hands have been so busy with scene changes, as beds, tables, desks, a chaise-longue, petrol pump and laundry-box are rushed on and off stage.
 The novel is possessed by the fantastic, visionary imagination of Saleem. As written by Rushdie and beautifully played by Zubin Varla, who conveys both the character’s vulnerability and swaggering assurance, Saleem’s one of the magical mystery children, born on the midnight moment of India’s Independence. These unique offspring, in Saleem’s view, represent the spirit of political hope that’s later cruelly extinguished. But Supple, usually such a questing director, has settled for the wrong earth-bound approach and tried to cram too much into three hours.
 On its own terms, though, this dramatised Midnight’s Children does offer a fascinating voyage into a family and its Indian history. The comedy of manners, involving outbreaks of sexual prudery and the dilemma of Saleem’s doctor grandfather (Kulvinder Ghir), smitten in 1915 by a femal patient (Meneka Das) whose body is forbidden his longing gaze, gives way to a turbulent family-drama in which politics fudely intervenes. Varla’s grandiose Saleem, victim of family secrets, is accordingly despatched to Pakistan.
 There torture, amnesia, a magicians’ ghetto, a seductive witch and Selva Rasalingam’s sinister Shiva ironically challenge and transform his sense of identity, depriving him of sexual potency and voices he hears in his head. The weird, wonderful sweep of Rushdie’s imagination may need a more exciting stage form. And Supple’s distillation of impassioned India-Pakistan enmities, often revealed when the rear panels of Melly Still’s design are dramatically drawn apart to disclose fighting warriors, is rather plodding. But enough of Rushdie’s enchantment survives to cast a theatrical spell.
Until 23 February. Box office: 020 7638 8891
Too little magic in Rushdie’s realism
Midnight’s Children
Barbican 
Nicholas de Jongh

It’s years since I saw anything quite so strange as this epic feat of adaptation that transports the magic and realism, the fantasising and farce of Salman Rushdie’s big novel about post-war India and Pakistan from page to stage. I had to adjust my mind, ears and eyes to cope with the sheer scale of the novel experience. For Tim Supple’s RSC production, in an adaptation he has written with Rushdie himself and Simon Reade, is swept along in a hurly-burly of old cinema newsreel about India and Pakistan, new video film, old rock music from the West and newer sounds from the East. On the actual stage, scenes of assassination and political protest, warfare of the marital and military sort, weddings and torture, visions and ghosts and a moment of a nurse’s crucial wickedness in hospital come at us in a helter-skelter rush. The Asian actors perform with, finely drilled exuberance.
 Yet exhilarating as it is to experience the young hero-narrator, Saleem Sinai, dramatising his life and family-history, which he rightly sees as being intertwined with that of India’s, I cannot count this Midnight’s Children as a runaway success. The modest, touring adaptation by Martin Sherman of another great, related novel, EM Forster’s A Passage to India, now at Riverside Studios, enjoys what this production needs and conspicuously lacks – a theatre style of its own. Rushdie’s novel, whose realism has more than a touch of magic about it, with its feet on the ground and imagination floating in the clouds, has been given a literal-minded treatment, yet Midnight’s Children